Skip to main content

The Tax Agency has launched a large-scale, nationally coordinated operation to tackle tax fraud in the beauty sector

Operation ‘Nassus’

    • The findings of previous investigations at beauty salons and dermatology clinics, together with new information gathered, have led to the launch of a large-scale operation involving 90 companies and 70 specialist doctors
    • More than 440 Agency officials have visited 92 premises across the 15 autonomous communities under the general regime
    • Around 40 per cent of the specialists subject to inspection have safes, and there are fears that in some premises customers are not even allowed to make card payments, as has already been observed in previous cases

17 October 2019 – The Tax Agency has today launched a major operation across the 15 autonomous communities under the common tax regime to combat tax fraud in the cosmetic surgery and dermatology sector. The operation, codenamed ‘Nassus’, involves the launch of inspections into 90 companies and 70 individuals, primarily specialist doctors, but also people from their personal and family circles, with officials from the Agency’s Inspection Department visiting 92 clinics in this sector throughout the day.

The operation covers premises located in Andalusia (12), Aragon (4), Asturias (2), the Balearic Islands (3), the Canary Islands (6), Cantabria (1), Castile-La Mancha (4), Castile and León (3), Catalonia (16), Extremadura (1), Galicia (10), Madrid (11), Murcia (3), La Rioja (1) and the Valencian Community (15).

Operation ‘Nassus’ was coordinated by the Department of Financial and Tax Inspection, with the participation of 370 officials from the Inspection division, including staff from the IT Audit Units, the UAIs, as well as support from police officers and 79 Customs Surveillance officers from the Tax Agency.

Background

The operation launched today, which will continue over the coming months as the inspections now getting under way are carried out, follows a detailed analysis of the results of a series of audits carried out in recent years across the country on companies and professionals in the cosmetic surgery and dermatology sector, combined with the gathering of new sector-specific information relevant to tax matters.

It is also worth noting the strong growth the sector has experienced in recent years: Spain ranks twelfth in the world for cosmetic procedures and fourth in Europe, with nearly 400,000 procedures carried out each year.

The analysis carried out by researchers at the Tax Agency revealed that a significant amount of the actual economic activity was being concealed by the companies and specialists audited, a practice facilitated by the use of cash as the main means of payment.

In some cases, despite the large sums paid to cover the cost of cosmetic surgery, practitioners would not even accept card payment – a practice which the Agency’s investigators fear may be repeated at several of the premises now under inspection.

Consequently, the experience gained made it advisable to carry out this coordinated initiative at national level, with the aim of gaining direct access to the actual accounting and supporting documentation and information held by clinics and doctors’ practices, including their computerised information processing systems.

Cash and safes

In selecting the companies and individuals subject to searches and inspections, the Agency took into account a series of financial ratios (some of the companies had even filed tax returns showing losses in recent years, whilst their partners and directors – the doctors – displayed clear outward signs of purchasing power that were inconsistent with the company’s financial situation).

At the same time, given the widespread use of cash as a means of payment – which naturally makes it difficult to trace transactions – the practitioners benefited from a characteristic shared by most of their clients: they are private individuals who are not entitled to claim any tax deduction for the treatments they received.

According to the information available to the Agency, some of the professionals currently under investigation did not accept card payments at all: all payments were made in cash or, to a lesser extent, by bank transfer. In other cases, however, the proportion of payments made by card was particularly high, which could indicate that part of the income was being concealed in the form of cash.

In any case, and regardless of the varying proportions of payment methods used at each premises, the use of cash amongst those inspected is clearly widespread. Proof of this is that approximately 40 per cent of the individuals affected by the operation own their own safes.

Deterrent effect

During the audits that are now commencing, the relevant tax quotas – covering VAT, personal income tax and corporation tax – will be regularized, by analysing whether companies have been used as a front in the invoicing process for transactions, as well as the tax consequences arising from holding, where applicable artificially, ownership of assets and personal wealth through corporate structures.

However, as well as facilitating the detection and regularization of tax fraud, coordinated sector-specific operations such as the one now getting under way also pursue two further objectives of interest to the Tax Agency. On the one hand, to assess its functioning on the basis of facts and evidence

within the sector, by having access to information on actual economic ratios, cost structure, collection methods, etc.; on the other hand, to send a deterrent message to the groups involved in these practices, which not only have an impact on the public purse but also seriously distort competition within the sector itself, so as to steer their behaviour towards the proper payment of their tax obligations.

With these objectives in mind, the Agency has carried out a total of 17 sector-specific large-scale operations coordinated at national level in recent years (not yet including Operation Nassus), resulting in more than 1,600 cases being opened, of which more than 1,100 have already been concluded, with a total settlement amount of 258 million euros. The Agency plans to monitor the behaviour of these taxpayers in the years following the audits.